Cemented Versus Cementless Knee Replacement — Is One Better Than the Other?

Knee replacement technology has improved significantly over the years. Surgeons can now fix implants in place using either bone cement or a cementless technique that allows bone to grow into the surface of the implant.

Both options are reliable and have shown excellent outcomes. Is one better than the other?

Learning the differences between cemented and cementless knee replacement can make it easier to feel confident about your surgery.

How Do Knee Replacement Implants Attach to Bone?

During knee replacement surgery, doctors replace the damaged parts of your joint with new artificial surfaces in the form of metal and plastic. These need to stay well fixed to your bone for your knee replacement to work well.

Surgeons typically attach these components using either bone cement or a cementless technique.

The cemented method holds the implant in place right away. The cementless method has a rough surface so your bone can grow into it over time.

  1. Cemented Knee Replacement
    Surgeons have used bone cement for decades because it creates immediate mechanical fixation that holds the implant securely in place. It is often the best choice if your bones are soft. Cement has a long track record of helping people stay mobile for years.

    One benefit is that patients do not need to wait for the bone to grow around the implant. The joint is stable right after surgery. However, in some cases, the cement can wear down over time, which might cause loosening years later.

  2. Cementless Knee Replacement
    Rather than using bone cement, these implants have a textured surface that allows bone to grow into the implant. This biological bond becomes stronger over time and is designed for long-term stability. You might feel a bit more discomfort at first while your bone fills in around the implant. A successful outcome depends on proper alignment, bone quality, and healing.

Key Differences Between Cemented and Cementless Implants

The main difference lies in how the implant attaches to the bone. Cemented fixation provides immediate stability that theoretically gets weaker over time, whereas cementless fixation builds strength over time.

Cementing a knee replacement can add approximately 10-15 minutes to a surgical case, so surgical time in a cemented knee replacement is often 10-15 minutes longer than a cementless knee replacement. However, these differences are minor and should not affect the final results.

Outcomes and Long-Term Results

Both methods offer similar results for pain relief, movement, and patient satisfaction. After recovery, your ability to move should be about the same with either option.

Both types of implants are designed to last for many years.

Cementless implants are often used in younger or more active patients, while cemented implants remain a reliable option across all age groups. In either case, you can expect a high success rate.

Archives

Choosing Between Cemented and Cementless Knee Replacement

Cemented knee replacement provides quick stability and has a proven track record. It is often recommended for people who have lower bone density.

Cementless knee replacement does not use cement. Instead, your body naturally bonds with the implant. This option works well for active people who have strong bones.

Both methods are useful in today’s knee care. The best choice depends on the patient’s needs, not on one method being better than the other.

Patient Reviews

Patient Stories
Discover what patients are saying about their experiences with Dr. Drake LeBrun. From compassionate care to outstanding results, these reviews highlight his commitment to excellence in hip and knee treatments, advanced technology, and personalized care that restores mobility and improves lives.

Dr. Lebrun and his nurse Riley are the perfect hip team. I had been in severe pain for months. After the hip replacement, I immediately felt better! And still do 3 months later.

Angie F.

Mu Daughter has Down Syndrome.. she had a complete hip replacement and then broke her femur. Had to redo everything plus. Dr LeBrun stepped in and redid everything with much compassionate and knowledgeable experience.all the while dealing with my daughter. I would recommend him and Frondren.. 10++++

Eva H.

I like Dr. LeBrun’s mannerism, how well he listens as you discuss your concerns & and his knowledge & advice he gives. Highly recommend him.

Mike W.

Dr LeBrun is great, first time seeing him.
He listens to you and answered all my questions.

Cindy R.

Great communicator, was not in a rush, thoroughly answered all my questions and I left happy with my treatment plan.

Kelly L.

Dr Labrun was very professional, very detailed, very caring!

Bill C.

Dr. Lebrun is a wonderful surgeon. He really seems to care for you as a patient. He takes the time to explain the details and answer all your questions and concerns.
He got me back up on my feet! 🦶 🙏

Tony A.

When I go to see Doctor LeBrun, him and his staff always make me feel very comfortable and at ease!

Bob Loretta M.

Dr. LeBrun was very attentive and addressed all of my issues in a timely manner. His staff were very polite and friendly.

Phyllis G.

I have Never been treated so Well as I have been there. So Nice and Helpful

Rebecca A.

I am recovering from my second knee replacement with Dr LeBrun this year. The office is peaceful and quiet. Staff are friendly and professional. Dr LeBrun is friendly, knowledgeable, and very good at his job. I'm very thankful I found him and couldn't be happier with my surgeries!

Karen P.

This doctor is 5 star , very knowledgeable, friendly and he helped save my life and got all the infection out of my knee. I appreciate him and his staff. Thank you Dr LeBrun.

Trainer E.

As a Final Remark

My decision to use cemented or cementless fixation depends on several patient-specific factors, including age, sex, and bone quality. Fortunately, both options yield excellent results.

Call (346) 615-9391 to discuss your options and see how we can address the source of your knee pain.

Skip to content