Why Some Patients Qualify for a Partial Knee Replacement Instead of a Total Knee Replacement

Not every knee that hurts needs to be replaced, at least not entirely. That might be hard to believe after months of pain and stiffness that just won’t quit. But the knee isn’t one simple structure. The knee has different compartments, and if only one is damaged, you might not need a full replacement.

To see why this matters, let’s first look at how the knee works.

How the Knee Is Structured

Your knee actually has three separate compartments. The medial compartment sits on the inside, the lateral compartment on the outside, and the patellofemoral compartment is the area where your kneecap meets your thigh bone.

Any of these areas can develop arthritis by itself, or the damage can eventually affect more than one compartment.

A total knee replacement addresses the damaged surfaces across the knee joint as a whole. In contrast, a partial knee replacement focuses only on the damaged area and leaves the healthy parts of the joint untouched.

What Criteria Make Someone a Candidate for Partial Knee Replacement?

Only about 10 to 25 percent of people who need knee replacement qualify for the partial procedure. This is not because the surgery is uncommon, but because the requirements are very specific.

Generally speaking, a good candidate has arthritis in one compartment of the knee but healthy cartilage everywhere else. Their knee still moves reasonably well, their ligaments are intact, and they do not have significant deformities.

They have typically already tried the non-surgical options available to them and have not gotten enough relief to get back to living normally.

Patients with inflammatory arthritis, such as rheumatoid arthritis, are usually not ideal candidates. That type of arthritis does not stay in one place. It tends to affect the whole joint, which means a partial replacement is unlikely to fully solve the problem.

Why Age Alone Does Not Determine Candidacy

A lot of people assume partial knee replacement is only for younger patients, but that is not true. While it can be an option for younger patients, there is no strict age cutoff in either direction.

What matters more is the condition of the knee itself and the patient’s overall health. For some older patients, a less invasive procedure with a smoother recovery can actually be the better path.

Archives

How a Partial Knee Replacement Differs From a Total Knee Replacement

The biggest difference is what stays the same. Since only the damaged part of the knee is treated, patients keep their natural bone, healthy cartilage, and working ligaments. Patients who undergo partial knee replacement often report that the knee feels more natural afterward, which is consistent with the fact that most of the original joint is preserved.

Recovery is quicker, too. Most people are able to walk on the day of surgery and return to their usual activities in four to six weeks.

For a total knee replacement, recovery usually takes three to six months. There is also less blood loss during surgery, a smaller incision, and often shorter operative time and anesthesia exposure.

Patient Reviews

Patient Stories
Discover what patients are saying about their experiences with Dr. Drake LeBrun. From compassionate care to outstanding results, these reviews highlight his commitment to excellence in hip and knee treatments, advanced technology, and personalized care that restores mobility and improves lives.

Dr. Lebrun and his nurse Riley are the perfect hip team. I had been in severe pain for months. After the hip replacement, I immediately felt better! And still do 3 months later.

Angie F.

Mu Daughter has Down Syndrome.. she had a complete hip replacement and then broke her femur. Had to redo everything plus. Dr LeBrun stepped in and redid everything with much compassionate and knowledgeable experience.all the while dealing with my daughter. I would recommend him and Frondren.. 10++++

Eva H.

I like Dr. LeBrun’s mannerism, how well he listens as you discuss your concerns & and his knowledge & advice he gives. Highly recommend him.

Mike W.

Dr LeBrun is great, first time seeing him.
He listens to you and answered all my questions.

Cindy R.

Great communicator, was not in a rush, thoroughly answered all my questions and I left happy with my treatment plan.

Kelly L.

Dr Labrun was very professional, very detailed, very caring!

Bill C.

Dr. Lebrun is a wonderful surgeon. He really seems to care for you as a patient. He takes the time to explain the details and answer all your questions and concerns.
He got me back up on my feet! 🦶 🙏

Tony A.

When I go to see Doctor LeBrun, him and his staff always make me feel very comfortable and at ease!

Bob Loretta M.

Dr. LeBrun was very attentive and addressed all of my issues in a timely manner. His staff were very polite and friendly.

Phyllis G.

I have Never been treated so Well as I have been there. So Nice and Helpful

Rebecca A.

I am recovering from my second knee replacement with Dr LeBrun this year. The office is peaceful and quiet. Staff are friendly and professional. Dr LeBrun is friendly, knowledgeable, and very good at his job. I'm very thankful I found him and couldn't be happier with my surgeries!

Karen P.

This doctor is 5 star , very knowledgeable, friendly and he helped save my life and got all the infection out of my knee. I appreciate him and his staff. Thank you Dr LeBrun.

Trainer E.

Bottom Line

Every patient I see is different, with their own goals, imaging, and timelines. If you’ve been told you need knee replacement and want to find out if a partial could be an option, call my office at (346) 615-9391. I’m happy to answer any questions before you make a decision.

Skip to content